How it all beganโ€ฆ

Let's rationalise some of the design decision together!

Why Focus on Cognitive Ergonomics for H&M?

High user drop-off rates and cognitive friction

H&Mโ€™s app was losing users due to overwhelming choices and poor navigation flow. Users often felt lost and frustrated, leading to higher cart abandonment and low engagement.

An Opportunity to Enhance User Experience and Retention

By applying cognitive design principles like Hickโ€™s Law and Fittsโ€™ Law, we streamlined navigation and reduced decision overload. This led to improved user satisfaction and a more fluid shopping experience.

In the end, it was about simplifying complexity for usersโ€”and it worked.

Next up, research

Why did H&M struggle with user engagement?

Based on usability testing and user reviews, we hypothesized that cognitive overload and complex navigation were major factors affecting user satisfaction. The app's heavy decision-making requirements made it cumbersome for users to complete tasks efficiently.

Talking to users

We conducted 1:1 usability testing with 40 participants (both novice and expert users) and gathered essential insights:

  1. Novice Users: Found it difficult to navigate the app, often abandoning tasks midway due to complex steps.

  2. Expert Users: Experienced friction during checkout and product filtering, slowing down what should be a seamless process.

Key user feedback:

The primary findings included:

  1. High Abandonment Rates: The checkout process was cumbersome, leading to cart abandonment.

  2. Delayed Decision-Making: Complex filters and categories slowed down product discovery.

  3. Unclear Navigation: Key features were hidden or buried deep in the menu, impacting user task completion times.

Hierarchical Task Analysis (HTA)

HTA revealed redundant steps that complicated the user journey. For instance, tasks like applying filters or completing a purchase were scattered across different sections, resulting in unnecessary complexity.

Task Breakdown Example:

Finding and Purchasing a Jacket: Required over 12 steps, many of which were repetitive or disorganized, causing users to feel lost and fatigued. A more streamlined approach was essential to reduce this mental workload.

Insights

Heuristic Evaluation

We applied Jakob Nielsenโ€™s 10 heuristics to evaluate usability, identifying key issues across several areas:

  1. Visibility of System Status: Users didnโ€™t always receive feedback when completing important actions, leaving them uncertain.

  2. Error Prevention: No safeguards were in place to prevent users from accidentally deleting items or selecting the wrong filters.

  3. Recognition vs. Recall: Users had to rely on memory to complete tasks like revisiting products they had previously viewedโ€”this caused confusion and slowed down the process.

Cognitive Principles Applied

HICKโ€™S LAW

Hick's Law states that the time it takes to make a decision increases with the number of choices available. We applied this principle by:

  1. Reducing Decision Points

We minimized the number of options displayed at each step, particularly in the product filtering process. Users were only shown relevant, prioritized options, speeding up decision-making

  1. Streamlining the Checkout Process

By cutting down on the number of decisions users needed to make, we reduced cognitive overload, resulting in quicker, more efficient transactions.

FITTโ€™S LAW

Fitts' Law explains that the time required to move to a target area is a function of the distance to the target and the size of the target. To optimize user interaction:

  1. Increased Touch Target Sizes

Buttons and interactive elements were resized to make them easier to interact with, particularly on mobile devices. For example, we enlarged the โ€œAdd to Cartโ€ button to make it more accessible.

  1. Optimized Layouts

We reorganized key interactive elements to be closer to where users naturally rest their hands on mobile devices, reducing the time required for task completion.

  1. Sticky Checkout Button

A sticky โ€œCheckoutโ€ button was introduced to reduce the physical effort required to navigate back to the top of the screen.

NASA-TLX (Task Load Index)

We used NASA-TLX to measure the cognitive, physical, and temporal demand on users while interacting with the app. Key findings indicated high cognitive strain during:

  1. Multi-Step Processes

Users experienced elevated mental workload when navigating through multiple, disjointed steps. We addressed this by consolidating actions and simplifying complex workflows, reducing mental fatigue.

  1. Checkout

The checkout process was found to be particularly stressful for users, contributing to frustration and task abandonment. By simplifying the flow and reducing unnecessary steps, we significantly reduced the mental effort required to complete purchases.

In many instances, users were unsure if their actions had been successful. To alleviate this:

  1. Clear Confirmation Messages

We implemented visual and auditory feedback to confirm successful actions like adding items to the cart or completing a purchase.

  1. Progress Indicators

Task progress bars were added to longer processes like checkout, giving users a sense of control and clarity on how much of the process remained.

Redesigned Screens

While these improvements were based on user testing and cognitive principles, the numbers tell the real story. Hereโ€™s how we validated our redesign using statistical analysis:

Statistical Data Analysis: The Proof is in the Data

NASA-TLX Data Validation

We used chi-square tests to analyze user mental workload. The results confirmed significant cognitive strain during multi-step processes like checkout, reinforcing the need for simplified task flows.

SUS Score Validation

Through a Z-test, we evaluated the SUS scores of novice and expert users. The test indicated that both groups experienced significant improvements in usability after the redesign, proving the success of our changes.

Usability Testing

A 2-tailed binomial test comparing pre- and post-redesign success rates showed a significant increase in task completion. This statistical validation highlights the effectiveness of our simplifications.

Hickโ€™s Law

Through scatter plot data, we found a positive correlation between reducing choices and faster decision times, further supporting our approach to simplifying product filters.

Final Takeaway!

By integrating cognitive principles with rigorous statistical validation, we were able to deliver a more intuitive and efficient user experience on the H&M app. This approach not only improved usability but ensured that every decision was backed by data, leading to a truly user-centered redesign.

Wrapping up, thank you!

If youโ€™re still here, then I know you have found something interesting, or everything interesting maybeโœจ

How it all beganโ€ฆ

How it all beganโ€ฆ

Let's rationalise some of the design decision together!

Let's rationalise some of the design decision together!

Why Focus on Cognitive Ergonomics for H&M?

Why Focus on Cognitive Ergonomics for H&M?

H&Mโ€™s app was losing users due to overwhelming choices and poor navigation flow. Users often felt lost and frustrated, leading to higher cart abandonment and low engagement.

H&Mโ€™s app was losing users due to overwhelming choices and poor navigation flow. Users often felt lost and frustrated, leading to higher cart abandonment and low engagement.

There was an Opportunity to Enhance User Experience and Retention

In the end, it was about simplifying complexity for usersโ€”and it worked.

In the end, it was about simplifying complexity for usersโ€”and it worked.

Why did H&M struggle with user engagement?

Why did H&M struggle with user engagement?

The primary findings included:

The primary findings included:

Heuristic Evaluation

Heuristic Evaluation

We applied Jakob Nielsenโ€™s 10 heuristics to evaluate usability, identifying key issues across several areas:

  1. Visibility of System Status: Users didnโ€™t always receive feedback when completing important actions, leaving them uncertain.

  2. Error Prevention: No safeguards were in place to prevent users from accidentally deleting items or selecting the wrong filters.

  3. Recognition vs. Recall: Users had to rely on memory to complete tasks like revisiting products they had previously viewedโ€”this caused confusion and slowed down the process.

We applied Jakob Nielsenโ€™s 10 heuristics to evaluate usability, identifying key issues across several areas:

  1. Visibility of System Status: Users didnโ€™t always receive feedback when completing important actions, leaving them uncertain.

  2. Error Prevention: No safeguards were in place to prevent users from accidentally deleting items or selecting the wrong filters.

  3. Recognition vs. Recall: Users had to rely on memory to complete tasks like revisiting products they had previously viewedโ€”this caused confusion and slowed down the process.

Reducing Decision Points

Reducing Decision Points

We minimized the number of options displayed at each step, particularly in the product filtering process. Users were only shown relevant, prioritized options, speeding up decision-making

We minimized the number of options displayed at each step, particularly in the product filtering process. Users were only shown relevant, prioritized options, speeding up decision-making

Streamlining the Checkout Process

Streamlining the Checkout Process

By cutting down on the number of decisions users needed to make, we reduced cognitive overload, resulting in quicker, more efficient transactions.

By cutting down on the number of decisions users needed to make, we reduced cognitive overload, resulting in quicker, more efficient transactions.

Increased Touch Target Sizes

Increased Touch Target Sizes

Buttons and interactive elements were resized to make them easier to interact with, particularly on mobile devices. For example, we enlarged the โ€œAdd to Cartโ€ button to make it more accessible.

Buttons and interactive elements were resized to make them easier to interact with, particularly on mobile devices. For example, we enlarged the โ€œAdd to Cartโ€ button to make it more accessible.

Optimized Layouts

Optimized Layouts

We reorganized key interactive elements to be closer to where users naturally rest their hands on mobile devices, reducing the time required for task completion.

We reorganized key interactive elements to be closer to where users naturally rest their hands on mobile devices, reducing the time required for task completion.

Sticky Checkout Button

Sticky Checkout Button

A sticky โ€œCheckoutโ€ button was introduced to reduce the physical effort required to navigate back to the top of the screen.

A sticky โ€œCheckoutโ€ button was introduced to reduce the physical effort required to navigate back to the top of the screen.

Clear Confirmation Messages

Clear Confirmation Messages

We implemented visual and auditory feedback to confirm successful actions like adding items to the cart or completing a purchase.

We implemented visual and auditory feedback to confirm successful actions like adding items to the cart or completing a purchase.

Progress Indicators

Progress Indicators

Task progress bars were added to longer processes like checkout, giving users a sense of control and clarity on how much of the process remained.

Task progress bars were added to longer processes like checkout, giving users a sense of control and clarity on how much of the process remained.

Redesigned Screens

Redesigned Screens

Final Takeaway!

Final Takeaway!

By integrating cognitive principles with rigorous statistical validation, we were able to deliver a more intuitive and efficient user experience on the H&M app. This approach not only improved usability but ensured that every decision was backed by data, leading to a truly user-centered redesign.

By integrating cognitive principles with rigorous statistical validation, we were able to deliver a more intuitive and efficient user experience on the H&M app. This approach not only improved usability but ensured that every decision was backed by data, leading to a truly user-centered redesign.

Wrapping up, thank you!

Wrapping up, thank you!

If youโ€™re still here, then I know you have found something interesting, or everything interesting maybeโœจ

If youโ€™re still here, then I know you have found something interesting, or everything interesting maybeโœจ

  • Letโ€™s Create Something Great

I'm all about transforming ideas into designs that resonate. Whether you're looking to collaborate or need a fresh perspective, I'm eager to bring innovative solutions to the table.

I'm all about transforming ideas into designs that resonate. Whether you're looking to collaborate or need a fresh perspective, I'm eager to bring innovative solutions to the table.

P.S. I'm gearing up for an exciting graduation project starting this January. Got something in mind? Letโ€™s chat!

P.S. I'm gearing up for an exciting graduation project starting this January. Got something in mind? Letโ€™s chat!

  • Letโ€™s Create Something Great

I'm all about transforming ideas into designs that resonate. Whether you're looking to collaborate or need a fresh perspective, I'm eager to bring innovative solutions to the table.

P.S. I'm gearing up for an exciting graduation project starting this January. Got something in mind? Letโ€™s chat!

  • Letโ€™s Create Something Great

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.